Skip to main content
deleted 3 characters in body
Source Link
Alex
  • 50.3k
  • 13
  • 28

I don't think we shouldn'tshould do anything. As far as I can tell, the user has not violated any site rules by posting, or by giving the impression of being a rabbi. Anyone is allowed to post here as long as they follow the rules, even if they are not a rabbi, or even if they are not Jewish.

Moreover, it is not our job to police content based on the identity or worldview of users. Any content that is posted is subject to the same system of peer review as anyone else's content. I see it as a dangerous slippery slope to police content in this manner. It is not such a big leap from deleting content because it was posted by a Christian missionary to deleting content because it was posted by someone from a different branch of Judaism, or someone with a "wrong hashkafa" or from a "bad yeshiva". And it would only be downhill from there.

I don't think we shouldn't do anything. As far as I can tell, the user has not violated any site rules by posting, or by giving the impression of being a rabbi. Anyone is allowed to post here as long as they follow the rules, even if they are not a rabbi, or even if they are not Jewish.

Moreover, it is not our job to police content based on the identity or worldview of users. Any content that is posted is subject to the same system of peer review as anyone else's content. I see it as a dangerous slippery slope to police content in this manner. It is not such a big leap from deleting content because it was posted by a Christian missionary to deleting content because it was posted by someone from a different branch of Judaism, or someone with a "wrong hashkafa" or from a "bad yeshiva". And it would only be downhill from there.

I don't think we should do anything. As far as I can tell, the user has not violated any site rules by posting, or by giving the impression of being a rabbi. Anyone is allowed to post here as long as they follow the rules, even if they are not a rabbi, or even if they are not Jewish.

Moreover, it is not our job to police content based on the identity or worldview of users. Any content that is posted is subject to the same system of peer review as anyone else's content. I see it as a dangerous slippery slope to police content in this manner. It is not such a big leap from deleting content because it was posted by a Christian missionary to deleting content because it was posted by someone from a different branch of Judaism, or someone with a "wrong hashkafa" or from a "bad yeshiva". And it would only be downhill from there.

Source Link
Alex
  • 50.3k
  • 13
  • 28

I don't think we shouldn't do anything. As far as I can tell, the user has not violated any site rules by posting, or by giving the impression of being a rabbi. Anyone is allowed to post here as long as they follow the rules, even if they are not a rabbi, or even if they are not Jewish.

Moreover, it is not our job to police content based on the identity or worldview of users. Any content that is posted is subject to the same system of peer review as anyone else's content. I see it as a dangerous slippery slope to police content in this manner. It is not such a big leap from deleting content because it was posted by a Christian missionary to deleting content because it was posted by someone from a different branch of Judaism, or someone with a "wrong hashkafa" or from a "bad yeshiva". And it would only be downhill from there.