5

Some sites on the SE network don't like cross-posting at all, while others think that it can be okay, in certain situations.

What does the Mi Yodeya community think about cross-posting, where the question in question is perfectly on-topic on both sites, or could be slightly modified to match both?

See the discussion on MSE about this question in general; but does the community here mind if a question previously posted, let's say, on Lifehacks, were to be reposted here?

6

I think that it's fine to post the same question (or very similar questions) to Mi Yodeya and another SE site, as long as:

  • The two posts are on-topic on the two target sites.

  • They are phrased appropriately for the two target sites.

  • The question posts on the two sites each contain a link to the other.

There are questions that would benefit by being addressed both by a community of experts on Judaism and by a community of experts on something else. For example, a question about the history of some Jewish practice could work here and on History.SE. There are probably people in each community who have expertise in the history of Judaism and who do not happen to frequent both sites. In addition, the history of a particular practice may be different from the point of view of Jewish tradition and from the point of view of the scholarly consensus in the secular discipline of history, so correct answers on the two sites may not be the same.

It is important to make sure that each post is up to the quality and topicality standards of the site that it's posted to. Given that these standards differ from site to site, the author should make sure to be considerate of the particular standards of both sites, especially if one of them is less familiar. Such consideration may result in the questions being stated in materially different ways, or it may not.

Also, note that even the exact same worded question on, for example, MY and another religion site are essentially different questions as they are asking from two different perspectives. Users should consider what kind of answer they seek.1

The question posts should link to each other so that readers of each site who are less familiar with the other site will be able to make easy reference to both communities' treatments of the question. In addition, ready reference to relevant information on another site could inform answers on this one.

1. From a comment by DoubleAA

  • 4
    I agree with this answer (though I don't feel strongly about the cross-linking). If a question is on-topic and appropriately written for here, I don't much care if it has also been asked on some other SE site -- the answers will be different because the communities and their expertises are different. Questions that are on-topic here on Mi Yodeya could also fit on History, Seasoned Advice, Philosophy, possibly the other religion sites, DIY (think Sukkot), and probably others -- apparently including LifeHacks. :-) – Monica Cellio Dec 18 '14 at 21:35

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .