7

We have and I see now , but no . Questions that are actually about the State of Israel frequently are tagged even if they have nothing to do with the Land, per se. This strikes me as silly.

Shouldn't we have a tag?

Example candidate questions:

| |
9

UPDATE: This has been implemented.


I propose that we:

  • Remove as a synonym for , since that just creates confusion now that there are separate tags for the Land and the State (and the People, for that matter).

  • Update the tag wiki excerpt for to something along the lines of:

    Questions related to the religiously-defined geographical area, the Land of Israel.

    and add a tag wiki that notes that questions related to the modern State of Israel as a political entity should be tagged .

  • Create , with a tag wiki excerpt along the lines of:

    Questions related to the modern geopolitical entity, the State of Israel, and life within it.

    and a tag wiki that notes that questions related to the Land of Israel as a religiously-defined geographical area should be tagged and that being about the State of Israel doesn't ipso facto make the question on-topic.

  • Create a synonym for it: .

  • Apply this tag to all questions currently tagged , and remove that tag, since it's more granular than necessary.

  • Consider applying this tag to each question about or relating to the geopolitical entity of the State of Israel and life within it.

  • Consider removing from each question that bears it and isn't about the Land of Israel per se.

| |

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .